A Medley of Interesting Disability Cases: Reviewing 2013 Cases

Another year has passed, and what better way to celebrate than by taking a look at the various interesting disability cases that have been issued during that time. This year they are collected in the Medley.

In this booklet I have summarized a couple of dozen individual and group disability opinions that were issued by both state and federal courts primarily over the 2013 calendar year. As is the case with each of my yearly collections, the cases included are meant to be illustrative of how judges resolve various issues, but those cases are not necessarily the only recent cases pertinent to each issue discussed. I have included both DI and LTD cases, with a focus on substantive over procedural issues (though both are included).

The format of this year’s Medley is the same as that of past collections: I have summarized the pertinent facts of each case and set forth how the court ruled on certain of the issues raised. At the conclusion of each case summary, I have provided my personal thoughts in a “Lessons Learned” section.

For those keeping track, this sixth booklet is the latest in a series that includes: (1) the Potpourri (2008 cases); (2) the Cornucopia (2009 cases); (3) the Smorgasbord (2010 cases); (4) the Cavalcade (2011 cases); and (5) the Ensemble (2012 cases). I am hopeful that collectively they provide a gestalt-ish “feel” for how courts seem to be resolving the issues that we all face. I am also hopeful that these summaries provide helpful guidance to those in the industry, whether they be making the initial decisions (the examiners and others working for disability carriers and third party administrators), giving legal advice about those decisions (in house counsel), defending those decisions (outside counsel), or performing other functions. We can all learn from the experience of the litigants whose disputes were resolved in these cases.

I would like to thank very much Natalie Ferrall, who gave significant time and great insight in assisting me with this publication.

If you would like a copy of this year's publication, or any prior year, please email me here.

 

Leave a Reply